Page ulrey senior deputy prosecuting attorney, seattle, wa, dr. Undue influence and financial exploitation huffpost. Download articles and the undue influence worksheet by dr. Undue influence occurs when someone exerts pressure on an individual, causing that individual to act contrary to his or her wishes and to the benefit. Undue influence maybe presumed where there is a pre active relationship of confidence between two parties to a contract as a result of which one places trust in the other and the contract between them is unfavourable to the party who places trust in the other.
The pdf for the issue in which this article appears is available for download. But knowing the definition of undue influence is only the first step. Like many legal terms, the actual legal requirements to demonstrate undue influence are far more precise than the average layperson may think. Undue influence synonyms, undue influence pronunciation, undue influence translation, english dictionary definition of undue influence. So, any time we can find some clarification, its worth taking a break to look it over. His wife nikki has died of cancer, and hes caring for his daughter sarah while negotiating a custody settlement between his sisterinlaw laurel and her exhusband, senator jack vega, over 17yearold. If the testator has been coerced into creating a will in a particular manner, then it is termed as undue influence which can be used as grounds to challenge a. Cleyburn mccauley induced bond sneed denson to divorce her husband by falsely telling her he was separated from his wife. Undue influence legal definition merriamwebster law. Undue influence definition of undue influence by the. Influencing the court to find for undue influence in. Pdf anatomy of an undue influence case researchgate.
To make the concept of undue influence useful, you have to know how to prove the existence of undue influence in a court of law. This will enable the person influenced to have the contract set aside as against a. Brien, undue influence was classified into 3 classes. Undue influence occurs when one party to a transaction is able to influence the decisions of another party to the transaction. It is a doctrine of equity that a contract, deed, donation, or testamentary disposition can be set aside if the court finds that someone has exercised undue influence over.
In the principal arizona case finding undue influence, the evidence is particularly strong. Undue influence is an equitable doctrine whereby a person takes advantage of a position of. Undue influence may take the form of isolating the weaker person, promoting dependency, or inducing fear and distrust of others, among other manipulations. There is no need for an existing relationship between the parties to prove actual undue influence. Anybody whos ever had a pushy girlfriend or boyfriend knows what undue influence feels like. The first blog dealt with the courts comments regarding the propriety of capacity assessors opining on whether undue influence was exerted on the deceased. Undue influence is a concern in situations when trusts, wills, deeds, and those with significant financial assets are involved, especially for the elderly or frail individuals and those who are debilitated. For example, if a physician executes an unreasonably favorable contract with a patient, the physician must be able to prove heshe did not exercise undue. How to evaluate a case of undue influence frank elder law.
This is the second blog we have written about the court of appeal for ontarios decision in vanier. By following these guidelines, you should be able to give clients a good evaluation about whether a case of undue influence is worth pursuing. Some people have said, i know it when i see it, making the term a matter of. Undue influence is a legal term for excessive or inappropriate manipulation. Persuasion involved with undue influence most often takes place in locations where no witnesses are available to make observations. Expertconsultant for cases of undue influence, coercion, manipulation, diminished capacity, dementia, financial abuse, professional misconduct, contested divorce and prenuptial agreements. Undue influence in english law is a field of contract law and property law whereby a transaction may be set aside if it was procured by the influence exerted by one person on another, such that the transaction cannot fairly be treated the expression of that persons free will. Undue influence contract entered into under influence of.
Morgan president, the center for geriatric and family psychiatry, glas. He calls his girlfriend, jane smith, to bail him out. Effect of undue influence on the validity of a will. M i c h a e l c o y l e o speak of law as too blunt an instrument to. Virtually any act of persuasion that overcomes the free will and judgment of another, including exhortations, importunings, insinuations, flattery, trickery, and deception, may. Undue influence what is it and how does it effect wills. Undue influence in equity lecture equity gives relief on the ground of undue influence where an agreement has been obtained by certain kinds of improper pressure which were thought not to amount to duress at common law because no element of violence to the person was involved gh treitel, the law of contract. Where a contract is found to be entered into as a result of undue influence, this will render the contract voidable.
Descriptions and models for determining undue influence are found in the laws of ancient rome and also in the talmud. The case that most recently looked at undue influence and set out the elements of undue influence is edwards v edwards, a case in which a man who had been excluded from his mothers will brought a claim challenging the validity of his mothers will on the grounds that his brother had exerted undue influence on their mother to achieve this. A situation in which an individual is able to persuade anothers decisions due to the relationship between the two parties. Summary the doctrine of undue influence is used by courts to set aside certain inter vivos giftswealth transfers, transactions, and planning and testamentary documents, where, through exertion of the influence of the mind of the donor, the mind falls short of being wholly independent. The behaviors that make up undue influence have been well documented for nearly 2,000 years. Saying that there has been undue influence is often used as a reason to contest a will or estate plan, but what does it mean. Four elements must be shown to establish undue influence. Influence that prevents someone from exercising an independent judgement. Undue influence exists if a person used a position of power over the deceased to influence that person to change the will to benefit them. Undue influence, like mental capacity, raises the question of whether an individual is acting freely. Undue influence is usually only claimed in the event that the party is in a relationship wherein another person is able to influence their decisions. This will enable the person influenced to have the contract set aside as against a party who subjected the other to such influence. Understanding undue influence, dissecting it, defining it, and.
Undue influence is one of the most common ways to invalidate wills, but how do you prove it. Lawyer paul madriani becomes embroiled in his most baffling case at a most difficult time. That is, someone in possession of full mental capacity is not likely to be swayed by undue influence, manipulation, or coercion. It is sometimes said that an inference of undue influence should not be drawn unless the facts are inconsistent with any other hypothesis. Sykes, cela, has practiced law in pittsburgh for 25 years and lectures frequently on elder law topics to attorneys and other professionals. Undue influence tv movie 1996 cast and crew credits, including actors, actresses, directors, writers and more. In many cases the fact of undue influence cannot be proved by the direct evidence of the witnesses but is an inference to be drawn from other prven facts. There are many methods for assessing and understanding undue influence. Undue influence occurs when a party unfairly influences another to enter into a contract. Shirley undue influence is defined as the exercise of sufficient control over the person, the validity of whose act is brought into question, to destroy his free agency and constrain him. Duress is usually claimed as a factor in the conclusion that undue influence existed. Click here to download a copy of the undue influence worksheet. Vitiating factors in the law of contract wikipedia.
Undue influence refers to the pressure one person puts on another in a context that holds legal significance. The court of appeals comments on undue influence in the. Hence, it allows them to assess cases flexibly based on the particulate facts provided rather than looking at undue influence as a common law doctrine and applying the rules set strictly. Undue influence behavioral models bennett blum, md.
Undue influence is defined under section 16 of the indian contract act 1872 if a contract is entered into by obtaining consent through undue influence the contract is voidable. Undue influence legal definition of undue influence. Complexity in claiming for undue influence probate matters a will drafted by a deceased person can be contested on various grounds by the beneficiaries. The following aspects are discussed in this chapter. Undue influence is basically a more subtle form of pressure than those threats which are considered duress to prove undue influence, a party will need to do one of the following. Undue influence in law, a situation in which one person uses hisher position or authority to extract an agreement from another person that is regarded as unfairly favorable to the first person. Jon atack is an independent scholar on manipulation and undue influence.
Undue influence most often arises when a person is drafting a will or entering into a contract. It operates largely through the application of presumptions. With brian dennehy, patricia richardson, jean smart, alan rosenberg. A judicially created defense to transactions that have been imposed upon weak and vulnerable persons that allows the transactions to be set aside. Undue influence is divided into actual undue influence and presumed undue influence. So if a victim can establish actual undue influence relating to the subject transaction in question, that would suffice. Since undue influence is an equitable doctrine, the criteria set to define it ought to only provide a framework for judges to exercise their jurisdiction. A person who has been induced to enter into a transaction eg, a gift.
Part iii considers the functionally equivalent doctrines that exist in french and german law. In movies and novels one often hears the term, undue influence utilized to denote a testator being fooled or frightened into leaving their estate to some conniving person or relative. His first major book was the bestselling, lets sell these people a piece of blue sky. Ppt undue%20influence powerpoint presentation free to. Undue influence is a process whereby parties who have entered into a contract can be released if they entered into the contract under the influence of another, whether this was intentional or not a contract which has been entered into under undue influence occurs when one party uses their influence to persuade another to enter into a contract to the detriment of the.
Undue influence archives freedom of mind resource center. Understanding undue influence, dissecting it, defining it, and understanding the term, has proven elusive in social service and legal settings. First and foremost, any discussion on the law of undue influence must begin with allcard v skinner where cotton lj clearly stated that undue influence could be proved by establishing that the gift was the result of influence expressly used by the donee for the purpose, or, where the relationship between the donor and donee have at or shortly before the execution of the gift been. Testamentary capacity, undue influence, and the burden of proof. Undue influence is the equitable concept which supplements the common law vitiating factor of duress. U ndue influence occurs when a predatoryauthoritarian individual or group takes control over a persons beliefs, interests, thoughts, feelings, legal or medical rights, possessions, finances or behavior without that persons full knowledge and explicit consent, usually under false pretenses when people are under the spell of undue influence their beliefs and experience of reality will. Undue influences legal definition of undue influences. Imbalance of power between the parties is an important element. Normally undue influence can only be successfully claimed by a minor or an elderly person who has a guardian responsible for overseeing their legal or financial obligations. A will contest can present a bewildering forest of legal issues that can entangle the best lawyers. Such conditions as mental, psychological, or physical disability or dependency may be used to show susceptibility. First, it must be demonstrated that the victim was susceptible to overreaching. Undue influence is the legal term for someone exerting so much pressure on another that it overcomes that persons free will to execute contracts or make transactions. Undue influence law and legal definition uslegal, inc.
Undue influence is the most common ground for will contests and are often accompanied by a capacity challenge. Lets say john doe for whatever reason lands in jail for a night. This is no different from any ordinary case in which he who asserts a particular defence must prove it. Undue influence financial definition of undue influence. In exerting undue influence, the influencing individual. Furthermore, the contract attempting to be voided for undue influence does not have to be of manifest disadvantage to the claimant cibc mortgages plc v pitt 1994 1 ac 200. If one can prove undue influence, one can invalidate a will or trust. In english law, a vitiating factor in the common law of contract is a factor that can affect the. Ive blogged before about using the concept of undue influence to overturn a california will or trust. In many cases, the influencer has a special relationship with the testator, which creates a.
844 1150 1276 1087 1253 1030 789 1475 748 1517 756 1381 860 1585 1207 1417 1604 588 831 324 329 627 631 1003 837 1600 897 1300 1194 308 193 916 33 1451 646 338 1468 348 229